
This is an illustration from a "Little Red Riding Hood" book, and I chose this illustration solely for the little use of color within the image. Although we know this image was more expensive than a standard, black and white image, it was still cheaper than applying color to the entire image itself. I found this images use of color to be amazing. The use of color in Little Red Riding Hood elicited a strong response from the reader. It told us that she was in danger or something bad was going to happen within the story itself. Another place they used color, which was the same color used for Little Red Riding Hood's jacket, was in the words, which said, "she met the wolf." Because the colors match one another and the rest of the image, including the wolf, is either black or white, it tells us that there is something alarming going on in the story, and it makes the reader feel a sense of fear or urgency for Little Red Riding Hood.
I think McCloud's theories of color complicate my reading of images because I now know that not all comic book creators have the luxury of using color. Referring to the image above, if it would have been done in all black and white, I don't think it would have elicited the same response from the reader. It wouldn't have portrayed this sense of urgency as the colored image does here. It further complicates it because I think comics should be created with the use of color because it allows for the reader to have a deeper connection with the text, whereas McCloud thinks that although color has its perks, that black and white comics can and should have the same response. I just think that if a comic doesn't have color, it makes it harder for the reader to understand what is important in the panel, which makes me think that a black and white comic may need to add more dialogue to make sure the reader fully understands what is going on within the storyline.
You made excellent points about the emotions we can get from seeing colors and how colors can be used to identify heros and villains. Your points on comics being black and white confusing readers are also excellent. Like with manga, we read in black in white and there are only so many shades of black that could identify an emotion or an idea. The background could help with those but some color could really put emphasis on it.
ReplyDeleteYour points about the color being a luxury and how some comics need it. I agree that the image you selected above would not hold the same weight that it does with only that little bit of red, and the sense of urgency that it creates. I can also see where you are coming from when you say that color makes a reader create a much deeper connection to the characters. I've personally never really thought about it much, but I really see it.
ReplyDeleteIt is quite interesting just how influential color can be in the world of comics, especially in establishing symbolism and evoking certain emotions and themes. I notice that in a way it plays a sort of parallel in with line usage, which is what I discussed in my post As for the commerce aspect, I think that has changed quite a bit between the early days of comics and now. It may have been more difficult to do back when comics were just getting their starts, but nowadays with advances in technology and digital inking becoming more and more popular, I find that it is much harder to find any comics these days that are not in color. The only exceptions I can think of are newspaper comics strips and most manga. Funny how things change in just a few short years.
ReplyDeleteI like how you focused on the money aspect of making comics with color because I feel like it gets skimmed over. I also like how you point out the picture of little red because even though they only used one prominently bold color it works very well for the picture and it also saves money for the artist since they do not have to pay for printing in too much color. I also like how you pointed out that without colors, a comic might not be able to portray the panels as well and need more explanation. I do not know if I agree with you on that point but it definitely is something interesting to think about.
ReplyDelete